Submit a Claim - 24 hours
Many of the insurance companies we represent allow 24/7 claim reporting directly to the insurance carrier. Your Team at Balsbaugh Insurance is available to assist you in filing a claim during our weekly business hours. However, we recognize that cannot always be the case so you are welcome to either contact the carriers below directly or Mike B or Mike L on the Contact page for assistance. For other companies not listed below or to get an update of your existing claim, please contact our Team during business hours. After hours please contact Mike B or Mike L for emergency clam assistance.
Please be advised: the following direct-reporting options usually require an active policy number and complete details of the incident to start a claim:
Donegal Insurance Group
Call 800-877-9006 (available 24/7)
For a glass claim only, call 866-439-4527
Tuscarora Wayne Insurance Company
Call 570-746-9545 after hours or weekends
Or if you have an account through the company portal, file a claim online
Or if not an emergency and you do not have company portal access,
file a claim online
Lancaster Mutal
Monday-Friday 8am - 4:30pm call 888-764-7232 or email claims@lancastermutual.com
4:30pm Friday - 8am Monday call 610-413-5317 or email dmusante@claimadjustersinc.com
Rain and Hail
Call our agency to file a claim as soon as a loss is discovered.
